Check Reviews

You know how when you're shopping online, especially on Amazon, you sometimes look at the reviews and think, "Are these real? Or are they all from people who got a free product?" 

​Unfortunately, there are no longer automated tools that do the hard work for you like there once was. These have been shut down by the big boys and it kinda makes sense I suppose.

You can look at online groups, google reviews and local review sites like TrustPilot in Australia for some help, but you really need to vet things for yourself. Local retailers often have reviews from customers that are largely unedited so there’s that I suppose. Youtube is another good one.

​Some red flags:

1. Manual Inspection: Your Best Tool for Spotting Red Flags

This is your primary defense. By carefully reading and analyzing reviews, you can often spot inconsistencies:

• Look for Sudden Review Spikes: If a product suddenly gets a massive influx of 5-star or 1-star reviews in a very short period, especially if it's not a brand-new product, that's highly suspicious. Real reviews tend to trickle in more gradually.
• Generic or Overly Enthusiastic Language:
  • Too perfect/vague: Be wary of reviews that are exceptionally positive but offer no specific details about the product's features, how it was used, or its actual performance. They might use a lot of generic superlatives ("amazing," "perfect," "best ever") without substance.
  • Repetitive phrasing: If multiple reviews use the exact same or very similar wording, or if they all follow an identical structure, it strongly suggests they were copied, pasted, or generated by the same source.
  • Unnatural tone: Sometimes, the language just doesn't sound like a real person talking. It might be overly formal, stilted, or have awkward phrasing.
• Examine Reviewer Profile History:
  • New accounts / One-hit wonders: Check if the reviewer has only ever left one review (for that specific product) or if their account is very new with no other activity.
  • Reviews for unrelated products: A reviewer who leaves dozens of reviews for completely disparate products (e.g., car parts, baby toys, and anti-aging cream) all within a very short timeframe is a major red flag.
  • All 5-star (or 1-star) reviews: A reviewer who exclusively leaves perfect scores (or always the lowest) for everything they review might be biased, paid, or part of a coordinated effort.
• Lack of Specificity: Genuine reviews usually mention specific features, pros, cons, or personal experiences. Fake reviews often lack this detail because the reviewer hasn't actually used the product.
• Poor Grammar or Spelling: While not always a giveaway (everyone makes typos!), a high number of reviews with consistent grammatical errors or awkward phrasing can be a sign they're not from native speakers or are AI-generated.
• Timing and Context:
  • Reviews posted before product launch: This is a clear giveaway of a fake.
  • Incentivized reviews without disclosure: If a review clearly sounds like the person received something for free or at a discount, but they don't explicitly disclose that (which is often a platform's policy), that's a problem.
• Look for the "Verified Purchase" Badge: Most major retail sites (like Amazon) have this. While not foolproof, reviews from "verified purchasers" are generally more trustworthy as it means the platform confirmed they actually bought the item. A product with many glowing reviews but few "verified purchases" should make you cautious.

2. Cross-Reference and Consult Independent Review Sites

Don't just rely on reviews from the site you're buying from. Expand your search:

• Other Major Retailers: If you're looking at an item on one site (e.g., Amazon), check if it's also sold on other big retailers (e.g., Walmart, Best Buy, Target in the US; JB Hi-Fi, Big W in Australia). Compare the overall star ratings and read a selection of reviews there. Wildly different sentiments can indicate review manipulation on one platform.
• General Service/Business Review Platforms:
  • Trustpilot.com: This is a prominent platform focusing on consumer trust and transparency. While primarily for service-based businesses, many product companies also have profiles here. You can see how a company responds to feedback, which indicates their customer service commitment.
  • Google Business Profile (Google Reviews): For local businesses, checking their Google reviews is crucial. Look for patterns like many reviews coming from new accounts or generic names.
  • Yelp: Best known for restaurants and local services, but also covers other businesses.
• Industry-Specific & Expert Review Sites: These are often the most reliable sources for product quality and performance:
  • Consumer Reports (US), Which? (UK), CHOICE (Australia): These are independent, non-profit organizations that conduct their own rigorous, unbiased product testing. They don't accept advertising or free samples, making their reviews highly trustworthy, though often subscription-based for full access.
  • Tech & Electronics: CNET, Wirecutter (owned by The New York Times), PCMag, TechRadar, RTINGS.com (excellent for TVs, monitors, headphones with detailed testing).
  • Software/B2B: G2.com and Capterra.com are widely used for software reviews. While they do have vendor engagement, they generally strive for verified reviews and often require professional credentials or proof of use. Look for detailed reviews that highlight specific pros and cons rather than generic praise.
  • Home & Appliances: Good Housekeeping Institute, The Spruce.
  • Automotive: Edmunds, Kelley Blue Book.
  • Travel/Hospitality: TripAdvisor (for hotels, restaurants, attractions).
• Video Reviews (YouTube): Many YouTubers review products. Look for channels that seem unbiased, show the product in detail, demonstrate its features, and discuss both the good and bad aspects. Be wary of channels that seem to only promote products without critical analysis.

By combining these methods, you significantly increase your chances of making well-informed purchasing decisions, cutting through the noise to find genuinely useful feedback.

Ep335

Image created by AI